My first game idea -

[1ce]

Re: My first game idea -

EDITED BY VALK - INFRACTION GET.

[Zeos]

Re: My first game idea -

And get outta here, noob

That is 1cecold.

[Kolgeroth]

Re: My first game idea -

Nope, actually your more of a nub than I am because you only have

"Posts: 4"

While I have..

"Posts: 6"

OWNED!!

[ErikaFuzzbottom]

Re: My first game idea -

Except that your post just took away from your credibility. In fact, while I'm at it, you kinda overreacted to the criticism your dungeon game was getting. Nobody was trying to be mean, they were just trying to help you. There was nothing about it that really sounded that interesting, except for the "randomization", but that would've proven really difficult to pull off, especially with you being so new to creating games.

[Kolgeroth]

Re: My first game idea -

Credibility? I'm sorry if you can't have any humor in your messages but I've seen games I wouldn't even glance at. I don't understand how you can judge someone by 6 or 7 posts, or say how good a game is without playing it.
It's was an idea, and I never asked for a bunch of mixed opinions like "get out of here nooblol"! If you call that helping.

[Ryner]

Re: My first game idea -

I don't really think this guy has done anything to deserve the acid he's getting.

[Dusk Raven]

Re: My first game idea -

Nope, actually your more of a nub than I am because you only have

"Posts: 4"

While I have..

"Posts: 6"

OWNED!!

This is what I hate about the internet.

[Perversion]

Re: My first game idea -

Don't worry, Kolgeroth, 1ce is just some guy from the mag, trying to stir up trouble here. Ignore what he says. But, yeah, I stand by the criticism of your game idea I posted earlier.

[Tsunami]

Re: My first game idea -

At least he gave some details about his game, unlike a lot of the other new guys who post game ideas.

[Duel]

Re: My first game idea -

I think the hardest part would be trying to survive 20 floors of monster-infested rooms.

[ErikaFuzzbottom]

Re: My first game idea -

Credibility? I'm sorry if you can't have any humor in your messages but I've seen games I wouldn't even glance at. I don't understand how you can judge someone by 6 or 7 posts, or say how good a game is without playing it.
It's was an idea, and I never asked for a bunch of mixed opinions like "get out of here nooblol"! If you call that helping.

By credibility, I was actually talking about your OWNED post.

But there was also your "You hurt my feelings" reason for switching games. And nobody said how good your game was without playing it. For all we know you might've pulled out something decent. But I reiterate, nothing about it sounded good, and we had doubts that you as a new user would be able to handle creating a game with so much randomization, especially since RPGM3 doesn't have a randomization option by default. We're not trying to bash you. We're giving our honest opinions.

If it makes you feel better, 1ce got a strike for his offense.

[Kolgeroth]

Re: My first game idea -

Okay, thanks guys. Criticism is okay

Just don't take it seriously. Guess I could just make this Dungeon thing on RPGMaker 1, but I don't like the music, and the graphics are kind of bland..

[Tsunami]

Re: My first game idea -

You shouldn't revamp your idea based solely on the opinions of other board members, make the game you want to make, that's the most important thing.

[Kolgeroth]

Re: My first game idea -

Yeah well maybe I'll try some of the games made from you guys and see what I could work on. I'm still trying to figure out this PS3 transfering stuff though. I can't understand how to work it.

[Crythania]

Re: My first game idea -

I like the randomized dungeon idea. Reminds me of Diablo. That game was a blast!

Here's an idea. And I can't push this idea enough on these boards.

No. Random. Encounters.

Use event-based battles instead. It's more work, but in my humble opinion it's worth every second spent on it. Also, have very few event-based battles, not a whole dungeon floor filled with them. Make them challenging and interesting, few and far in between, with lots of other things going on in addition to the battling (like collectable items you can find, treasures you can find, or any number of things). In short, take out everything that gives "dungeon crawling" a bad rep and make it as interesting as possible.

Quality over quantity.

Here's another idea (inspired by yours).

Instead of trying to simulate a randomized effect, create several different versions of the game. Say, 5 different versions of the dungeon, perhaps each with its own difficulty level. Version 1 could be "Easy". Version 5 could be "Hard". At game-start, give the player the option to choose which version of the game he'll be playing.