Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Current gen console "desktop" interface

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Current gen console "desktop" interface

    Which do you prefer?


    I personally go with PS3 (of course), followed by Wii, and lastly the 360.


    The XMB just seems the most intuitive, the sleekest and least cluttered, and somewhat more sophisticated than either of the other two.

    The Wii's interface would be next for me. The "channel" system is okay, but adding a friend is not all that intuitive (for me, at least). After not having played for a while, I forgot that you needed to go into memo or notes or messages or whatever to add someone, and spent about 5 minutes poking around trying to find it. With the casual focus of the console, the "channel" thing with big bright "screens" works, but seems a bit simplistic.

    And I really do not even want to get into the train wreck that is the 360's interface. The old one was perfectly fine. I liked the blade format. Currently, I pretty much despise the layout. I guess if I was a teenager or in my early-mid 20s and played a lot of shooters and really needed sensory overload every minute of every day (the 360's target audience, it seems), I might like it better. For me, though, it's FAR too busy, cluttered, and haphazard-looking. Even still, the layout is fairly intuitive, and it's not all that difficult to find what you are looking for. It's moreso having to wade through all of that extraneous clutter to get to it.


    Being a more mature gamer, it seems as if Sony is targeting any demographic that I might fit into more than either of the other consoles. Besides the focus of a lot of their first party published software (The Last Guardian, Heavy Rain, Flower, etc) being on older gamers or those looking for something different and unique, the visualizers and the interface reflects this. The 360 has all the bright fractal/psychedelic stuff, and even though the PS3 only has 3, the Earth one and the other one that's not the wave both are more subtle, look better, and are not again geared for sensory overload.
    19
    Wii
    31.58%
    6
    PS3
    47.37%
    9
    360
    21.05%
    4

    #2
    Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

    Is this for looks only, or ease of use in general?
    http://www.youtube.com/user/Goufunaki

    Comment


      #3
      Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

      I voted 360, but it's basically a toss-up between theirs and Sony's, both have their issues but work fine and are fairly stylish (somewhat more so Sony's, but I like Microsoft's putting more information in an immediatel accessible position). I'm just less enthused about the Wii's interface, with the friend system on that platform just all fudged up by comparison.

      I would say I don't like the Zune integration. Preferred the separate video and music channels.
      "Never underestimate the predictability of stupidity."

      Comment


        #4
        Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

        I really dislike the 360 interface. Seriously. I feel like it's so much more cluttered than the PS3's. The XMB's so streamlined, in my opinion.



        Don't copy that floppy!

        Comment


          #5
          Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

          I'm judging more than the interface, but also the entire OS.

          wii is top for me. mostly because the layout can be customized completely. If I want to have all the system channels on page 1, I can. if I want to move all the games I'm currently playing to page 1 and shove all the system channels out of the way (aside from disc channel, of course), so I don't have to bother with them cluttering up my experience, I can.

          I'd like to put the DSi in second place, behind the wii. it has a similar completely customziable layout, and I really like that. but it's not one of the options.

          ps3 is second. I can't organize stuff as much as I want to aside from folders and various auto-sort options, and the constant "BLAH BLAH IS ONLINE" "BLAH BLAH IS OFFLINE" stuff annoys the hell out of me. also, the bothersome trophy setup crap that pops up every time you go to play many games is absolutely stupid. I also wish I could put saves (and memory card files) in folders so I don't have to scroll around in a giant list every time I want to prune some. PS3 lets you pause and prioritize downloads, which is nice. store can be annoying due to EXTREMELY random update times, and how long it takes all the icons to load in each section. constantly having to update the firmware to use online functions also sucks.

          360 is third, but it's more tied with the PS3, I think they both have some of the same problems, and they both have exclusive things that suck. in addition to the "BLAH BLAH IS ONLINE/OFFLINE" notices, it also has to tell you how many friends are online. and show you ads every time you turn it on. the store organization is also horrible, but being able to just select a game from your list and view all the downloads for it is great. to get access to all your games, you have to go to your games, then have it show all, then you get to scroll. the PS3 is much the same, but at least you can use folders on the PS3. the memory management of the 360 is a bit better. you don't have to install everything you download, and when viewing saves, they're already organized under each title, so you dont have to hunt for them in a big list.
          Last edited by Valkysas; 05-09-2010, 10:14 PM.



          Comment


            #6
            Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

            360's is a mess. It takes me 10 minutes to find what I'm looking for.
            Oh my god! You are so beautiful.
            I had no idea how beautiful you were.

            Comment


              #7
              Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

              Wii since Nintendo's proprietary OS' for Wii and DS(i) manage to not feel like they have to be explored to be understood. I prefer spending OS time knowing where what is and going to it without too much "figure out the layout".

              In essence, I enjoy simple "desktop" management.

              Comment


                #8
                Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

                Not sure about the 360, Valk, but if you go into system settings on the PS3, there is an option probably about halfway down that enables you to toggle friend notification messages on or off.



                Also, regarding customizing the Wii....what?!?! I've got some stupid Mario Kart Channel or something on the second "page," and I've never figured out a way to move or get rid of it. Where do you go to move stuff around? I've seen all the options and stuff, but I do not remember having seen anything about moving the "channels" around.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

                  You have to hold A+B and drag it.



                  Don't copy that floppy!

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

                    I like the "channels" interface of the Wii, but the fact that you need to use the Wiimote to do most stuff pretty much kills any love I have for it.

                    So I voted PS3.

                    Really, I'd like to be able to start a game disc that I have loaded in the system (for any system) by clicking one button at startup. Without pointing a wand at anything.

                    I still use my consoles almost entirely for games, as opposed to any other functions that they've added this generation. I do love the idea of DL games, though.
                    Last edited by Wavelength; 05-12-2010, 02:07 PM.


                    How Badly Do You Want It? (VX Ace) is now available for download! - no outside software necessary.

                    "I live and love in God's peculiar light." - Michelangelo

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

                      there is an option probably about halfway down that enables you to toggle friend notification messages on or off.
                      does not work for me. I turned it off long ago. it's still set to off. I still get notices.

                      as for the wii, yeah, hold A and B to pick stuff up and move it. if you want to delete channels, go into the save data menu.

                      OH. another annoying thing about the PS3. as far as I know, there's no way to sign out, short of going into system settings and disabling the internet connection.
                      Last edited by Valkysas; 05-12-2010, 02:41 PM.



                      Comment


                        #12
                        Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

                        Try one more time. Go under the System heading on the XMB, go to System Settings, choose Notification Messages, and turn it to Do Not Display.

                        As for signing out, go under the Playstation Network heading, go to the Account Management icon, press on the controller and choose Sign Out. I believe you can also toggle whether or not to Auto Sign In every time you turn the console on.


                        As for Wave above, I'm pretty sure that also under System Settings, there should be a setting to toggle Disc Auto Start on and off. If you insert a disc, it'll automatically start if you turn this on. On power up, I think it'll auto start whichever disc is inserted.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Re: Current gen console "desktop" interface

                          Try one more time. Go under the System heading on the XMB, go to System Settings, choose Notification Messages, and turn it to Do Not Display.
                          yeah, that's what it's set to. it still shows notifications. turned it on, then turned it off again. still showing notifications.

                          as for the signing out, good to know. it works. yay.



                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X