Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

    I'm not quite sure what to think. Is it required by law here in the states for games to be rated, or is that something companies like M$, Sony, and Nintendo require?

    http://www.gamespot.com/news/6185834...stnews;title;4

    Report: UK gov't to act on game ratings
    British newspaper The Guardian claims that ministers are set to introduce a legally backed rating system.
    By Laura Jenner, GameSpot UK
    Posted Feb 11, 2008 4:46 am PT

    Video games have not had an easy ride in the mainstream press of late, and this weekend was no exception. As the legal battle over the release--or not--of Manhunt 2 in the UK continues, The Guardian newspaper on Saturday claimed that the government is planning to introduce a "legally enforceable cinema-style classification system" for video games.

    The UK currently has two ratings systems: the PEGI rating, which is a purely advisory Europe-wide classification system, and those from the British Board of Film Classification, which are legally binding on retailers. The BBFC is an independent body, and currently gives ratings to only a small minority of games released in the UK.

    The Guardian reports that the problems of policing the current system, including the ease of buying games--whatever their age rating--over the Internet, may lead to a new British Standards Institution specification relating to filtering products to "protect children and other users from illegal or unsuitable content."

    Sue Clark of the BBFC told GameSpot that the organisation was "surprised" at the timing of the report in The Guardian, particularly considering that the Byron Review-- a government-commissioned study that is looking at both video games and the Internet--is not being released until March. Clark said, "The BBFC system is in place already, and we know through recent research that parents understand our ratings system, because it is common across games, films, and DVDs, whereas they are often confused by thinking of PEGI ratings, which are not legally enforceable, as difficulty ratings."

    Clark said that the organisation rated 258 games in 2007, of which 59 were given an 18+ rating and 92 deemed suitable for those aged 15 and over. The remaining 157 were given U, PG, or 12 ratings; although none of these games are required by the Video Recordings Act to be rated by the BBFC, publishers had voluntarily chosen to have the rating applied.

    GameSpot contacted UK games publisher body ELSPA for a statement, but one was not available at the time of publishing.
    http://www.youtube.com/user/Goufunaki


    #2
    Re: UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

    Yeah, ESRB rating is technically voluntary.

    http://www.esrb.org/ratings/faq.jsp#2

    Comment


      #3
      Re: UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

      It's voluntary but I don't think gamestores would stock an unrated game just like most stores refuse to stock Adult only titles. You're hurting yourself by not getting rated.

      Comment


        #4
        Re: UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

        Manhunt 2 wasn't even THAT good.

        Stupid controversy hyping the game.
        Screenshot Let's Plays

        Comment


          #5
          Re: UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

          I don't know about this one. That's one step away from a game being banned and illegal for content or even unpopular ideals. Maybe next they will track your purchases and even usages. Even may go so far as to make your usages public knowlege. No self respecting man could hide away in his basement and play the newest instalment of "Barbie Dance Beat" with out his business acquaintences finding out and cancelling their accounts with his company. Then Big Brother steals your socks out of the dryer. Tricky situation...

          Comment


            #6
            Re: UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

            Originally posted by Insultobot View Post
            I don't know about this one. That's one step away from a game being banned and illegal for content or even unpopular ideals. Maybe next they will track your purchases and even usages. Even may go so far as to make your usages public knowlege. No self respecting man could hide away in his basement and play the newest instalment of "Barbie Dance Beat" with out his business acquaintences finding out and cancelling their accounts with his company. Then Big Brother steals your socks out of the dryer. Tricky situation...
            Okay now, back to reality (honestly, Insultbot, do you really think that's going to happen. The UK is one of the LAST places that would put a ban on something over ideals presented--the controversy in videogames has always been about visual acts of debauchery, namely sex and violence, which I agree might be getting out of hand in alot of games. And I'm not even going to comment on your "Big Brother" conspiracy theory...)

            Personally, I like the idea. Sure government regulation has its drawbacks, but it would at least silence (or at least make their arguments illegitimate) proponents of videogame bans.
            "I love this moment so much I want to have sex with it"--Dr. Cox, Scrubs

            "I love this moment so much I want to cheat on that last moment with this one, marry it, and have lots of little moments."--Dr. Cox, Scrubs

            Comment


              #7
              Re: UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

              looks fine to me, doesnt appear to be a big deal. i didnt know that our rating where voluntary, though i dont recall any game or movie that was unrated but im sure there is a few.

              Thank you Ωbright for the sig fix!
              Card Three is released! You can find it here!

              Comment


                #8
                Re: UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

                Originally posted by Ivan Rosenguard View Post
                Okay now, back to reality (honestly, Insultbot, do you really think that's going to happen....
                Of course I don't actually believe it will go that far. I just don't like the idea and can see how the small things like this can end up having uninteded affects. My example being the most extreme and obviously nonbelievable, I just didn't think I would have to make such a clear distinction. But there you go.

                I personally agree that some games do try to go "too far" with there content. But you know what? If you don't like it, don't buy it. The message gets across. Besides all of this control is truly the parents responsiblity and its sad that they (the parents) don't take responsibility. Not just in the UK either.

                I will say I like the part about online purchasing BUT if a minor is purchasing online, where did he get the credit card? The parents. So if he can use a card online I'm sure he can also get around whatever age verifying they come up with. Knowingly or unknowingly the parents enabled their children to purchase anything online. Games or not.

                Again it is all up to the parents and this is just one more example of them dropping the ball and the goverment having to pick it up.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Re: UK government to create legally backed ratings for games.

                  Originally posted by Insultobot View Post
                  Maybe next they will track your purchases and even usages.
                  I really hope you don't use a credit card then. They already track our purchases, whether anyone but Bush and advertising companies care to pay attention is another story. Also Microsoft already tracks your gameplay as well since all of your data, achievements and such is stored on their servers. The Wii might since it keeps a local copy of how much time you've spent playing each game, but I'm not sure beyond marketing purposes if that data would be useful. So they're is more info out there than you can imagine, and companies just claim none of it is personally identifiable (and I imagine a good amount of them keep it that way, because if they were ever found out everyone would avoid said company). So really it's the corporations you should watch out for more than the gov't in terms of tracking what you do. But eh, keeping things private is getting harder and harder these days.

                  As for a legally backed system I don't see the big deal, as long as someone still carries the AO titles and none get banned because of the rating system then it's no different than the ESRB, other than minors might actually not be sold M rated games. Trust me when you're a business and you have a choice between making money and not having you're game rated, it's really no choice at all, so it's already 'enforced' by the 'free' market.
                  Last edited by thetruecoolness; 02-11-2008, 11:09 PM.
                  はじめまして。真(しん)の冷静(れいせい)です。どうぞよろしく。
                  http://www.thetruecoolness.com/

                  5198-2124-7210 Smash

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X